Signs Therapy Is Not Working & Ineffective
Signs Therapy Isn’t Working/Isn’t Effective/ Isn’t Helpful
You feel judged consistently
You feel invalidated consistently
You feel uneasy consistently
You received unsolicited advice telling you what to do
You have opinions and judgements imposed on you regarding religion, spirituality, and or other beliefs
Your personalities clash and are not a good fit (e.g. you want a direct therapist and they are more passive/says very little or they are too direct/pushy and you want someone more laid back/relaxed)
You feel pressured to say the right thing and to please them
Insensitivity to your beliefs, identities, background, culture, experiences
Your experiences are assumed rather than asked about/questioned/practicing curiosity/inquiry
When conflict and tensions occur, they are not brought up directly and talked about
Breaking confidentiality without good reason (e.g. suicidality, safety, elder abuse, child abuse, consultation)
You feel pushed/rushed to talk about things/topics you don’t want to/are not ready to talk about
You feel like treatment is going nowhere/very little (not seeing and experiencing changes after several months or getting worse)
The Therapist…
Avoids admitting mistakes when they occur
Seems bored and/or uninterested during session
Checks their phone during session regularly
Gives you unsolicited advice
Tells you about other clients and reveals personal, identifying information
Talks about themselves constantly or too much (excessive self disclosure)
Is defensive when you give them feedback or criticism
Doesn’t listen and respond to your concerns or feedback
Tries to be your friend
Doesn’t give you the time allotted to you (e.g. 45-minutes, 50-minutes, 60-minutes)
Goes over allotted time regularly in excess of 5-10 minutes (not a 1 or 2 time occurrence, but consistently)
Touches you without your consent and/or inappropriately
Flirts with you
Compliments you in a sexual or romantic way
Has sex with you (therapy never includes sex)
Pursues a dual relationship with you (hires you to do something, wants to be your friend, dates you, gets you to run errands for them, does personal favors for you)
Ends therapy to pursue a business, personal, and/or sexual relationship with you
Lacks adequate training in your issue, especially if it’s a niche/specialty area (e.g. OCD, ADHD, bipolar, psychosis, PTSD, eating disorders, personality disorders, substance use) and doesn’t let you know and/or refer out to someone who can help you
Doesn’t use evidence based therapy treatments
Is consistently unreliable (cancels sessions often repeatedly, often more than 5-10 minutes repeatedly, does not show up to session without notifying you)
Constantly forgets basic details about your life
Promises results and/or makes guarantees (there are no guarantee in therapy)
And more
Should Be a Consistent Issue
adverb: consistently
in every case or on every occasion; invariably.
"the vehicle consistently outperforms some of the best competitors"
Occurring over and over again without direct addressing, repair, and solving
An ongoing pattern
Therapy Is A Personal Experience
What works for one person may not work as effectively for another person. One person’s preferences will be in opposition to another person’s preferences.
One therapist could be a great fit for you and your needs. However, your friend or family member might not be a great fit for that person.
A therapist can be highly trained and still be a poor fit for a client. There are many factors contributing to overall therapeutic fit and matching including: personality, culture, gender, sexuality, race, ethnicity, temperament, lived experience, therapy approach/modality, and more.
Therapy is a highly personal experience. Not all therapists will be a good fit for your needs, concerns, and goals.
Tips
Meet with a few therapists for an initial 10-15 minute consultation to “shop around” and see who you seem to like/vibe with the most. However, some therapists may not offer a consultation. If they don’t, review their website to get a feel for their practice, personality, and approach.
If you are unsure after one session, either consider a different therapist or set up a follow-up session to clarify your concerns. Do not feel pressured to stay with one therapist.
Even if a therapist has specialized training and extensive experience in what you are seeking, you may not be a good fit due to factors such as personality differences, communication styles, cultural differences, etc.
There are so many types of therapy and therapists out there. As a consumer of therapy, you can do your due diligence and educate yourself on what your rights are and what to expect (see below for more information).
Look out for red flags in therapists. This can include: sexual advances, trying to be your friend, being repeatedly late, making sessions all about them and not you, and so forth.
If you find a therapist you find a good fit, try to stick with therapy at least for 3-6 months. It takes time for thoughts, feelings, and experiences to metabolize and make more sense. These are deeply entrenched patterns you are living with and attempting to alter and change. Practice patience.
Take a break as needed and communicate this need with your therapist. Healing is non linear.
Be as honest as possible with your therapist with what is working, what is not working, and whatever else you might not want to bring up. Feedback is helpful and a good therapist will value this feedback (even if it is not positive).
Try out different types of therapists based on context (e.g. time and place in your life). You might need a different type of therapist during school. Another type of therapist as you are looking for a job. Another type of therapist as you are in a long term relationship. And a different type of therapist when a sudden shift or adjustment occurs in life.
There are no guarantees counseling will solve all problems, or how quickly changes will occur. There are no miracle cures, but it improves the odds, particularly if you start early.
What Makes Therapy Effective?
Research shows using outcome measurement tools and asking for feedback throughout psychotherapy results in therapeutic effectiveness including more treatment gains and fewer client dropouts (Lambert, Whipple & Kleinstäuber, 2018).
Research shows the relationship between client and therapist accounts for client improvement (or lack of improvement) as much as, and probably more than, the particular treatment method/approach (Norcross and Lambert, 2018).
Moreover, the therapeutic alliance (a warm, supportive relationship) is also important. The therapeutic relationship is defined as: 1) Agreement on what the problem is, 2) What will be worked on in therapy, and 3) How this will be achieved (approach).
Research shows that clients and factors outside of the therapy account for about 40% of change (Assay & Lambert, 1999). This includes 1) The client’s level of motivation, 2) Perceptions of the therapy, 3) Commitment to the therapy framework, and 4) Integration of concepts into everyday life (Bohart & Wade, 2013).
Other factors include: 1) The therapeutic relationship, 2) Therapeutic alliance, 3) Therapy approach, 4) The therapist’s qualities, and 5) Client’s hope for change.
References
1) Lambert MJ, Whipple JL, Kleinstäuber M. Collecting and delivering progress feedback: A meta-analysis of routine outcome monitoring. Psychotherapy (Chic). 2018 Dec;55(4):520-537.
2) Asay, T.P., & Lambert, M.J. (1999). The empirical case for the common factors in therapy: Quantitative findings.
3) Bohart. A. C., & Wade, A. G. (2013). The Client in Psychotherapy. In M. J. Lambert (Ed.), Bergin and Garfield’s Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change (6th ed., pp. 219-257). Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
4) Norcross, J. C., & Lambert, M. J. (2018). Psychotherapy relationships that work III.Psychotherapy, 55(4), 303–315.
5) Lambert, M. J. (1992). Psychotherapy outcome research: Implications for integrative and eclectical therapists. In J. C. Norcross & M. R. Goldfried (Eds.), Handbook of psychotherapy integration (pp. 94–129). Basic Books.